📣 Brokers: Get Found When Buyers Are Actually Shopping
Claim your free profile in the insurance brokers directory and compete on value, not just price.
If you’ve been shopping for car insurance, you’ve probably heard some version of this:
“Brokers take a hidden 15% commission. Go direct and save.”
Sounds clean. Feels like a hack. But in Canada, that number isn’t a universal truth, and focusing on it can push you into the wrong decision in the Car Insurance Broker vs Direct conversation.
Here’s the simple reality:
- Broker pay (commission) is real, but it’s usually built into how policies are priced, and it varies by insurer, product, and province.
- For personal auto, many insurer disclosures put commissions around 10% to 12.5% (not always 15%). [Chubb]
- What matters more than the commission headline is: what you get for the price, how many markets you can access, and whether your info stays controlled while you compare in Car Insurance Broker vs Direct decisions.
Quick comparison: Ontario vs BC vs Alberta (2026 context)
| Province | “Direct vs broker” reality | 2026 thing that actually matters |
|---|---|---|
| Ontario | Private insurers. Brokers can shop multiple carriers. Direct is one carrier. | Accident benefits change July 1, 2026 (more choices means more ways to accidentally underinsure). [FSRA Ontario] |
| BC | ICBC Basic is required (ICBC is the sole provider). Optional coverage can be shopped. | ICBC has stated Basic rates steady until March 31, 2026 (so “saving big” is often about optional coverage and discounts). [icbc.com] |
| Alberta | Private market. Lots of shopping, but pricing is still risk-based. | Alberta has a 7.5% “good driver” rate cap in 2025 and 2026 if you qualify. [Alberta.ca] |
Quick tip: If a quote is dramatically cheaper, assume coverage changed until proven otherwise. Price-only comparisons are where people get burned.
What “broker” and “direct” actually mean
Car insurance broker
A broker is a licensed professional who can usually shop your policy across multiple insurers (depending on markets), help you compare coverage, and place the policy.
If you want a quick Ontario example, here’s a practical reference: car insurance broker.
Direct insurance (direct writer)
A direct insurer sells their own policies only. You’re not paying a broker, but you’re also not comparing multiple carriers through that channel in Car Insurance Broker vs Direct shopping.
About that “hidden 15% commission”
The better question is not “is there commission?” It is: Does your channel help you get the right coverage at a competitive price, without creating a privacy mess?
1) The “15%” headline is too blunt
Some insurers publicly disclose broker compensation around 10%–12.5% for personal auto. That does not make every insurer identical. It just makes “15%” a shaky blanket claim in Car Insurance Broker vs Direct debates. [Chubb]
2) Commission does not automatically mean “you paid extra”
In many cases, commission is part of the insurer’s distribution cost (direct insurers still pay for call centres, marketing, sales teams, and acquisition). The cost exists either way. The difference is what you get for it.
Source example: Chubb intermediary compensation practices
Takeaway: do not shop on commission headlines. Shop on comparable coverage.
When direct wins vs when a broker wins
✓ You want a sanity-check on coverage, not just price
✓ You want multiple markets without repeating forms
✓ You want help spotting what changed between options
✓ You already know the limits and endorsements you want
✓ You are willing to compare multiple direct insurers yourself
✓ You are comfortable self-managing coverage tradeoffs
Neither model is “better.” The mistake is assuming “direct” always saves money because “commission is gone.” Most of the time, the biggest savings come from matching your profile to the right pricing model, not from chasing a commission myth in Car Insurance Broker vs Direct shopping.
Ontario: why this matters more in 2026
Ontario’s big shift is accident benefits. As of July 1, 2026, Ontario changes make many accident benefits optional, while medical, rehab, and attendant care remain mandatory. [FSRA Ontario]
If a quote looks dramatically cheaper, ask:
• “What changed in the accident benefits?”
• “Did anything become optional that used to be included?”
• “Is this actually comparable coverage, or just a cheaper package?”
If you want a quick Ontario-only breakdown, this internal explainer is handy: Ontario auto insurance changes before 2026.
Ontario disclosure: In Ontario, brokers are expected to provide mandatory disclosures no later than the time of quote (and confirm in writing). [RIBO]
BC: the broker vs direct story is different because of ICBC
In BC, ICBC is the sole provider of Basic insurance, and ICBC has stated Basic rates would remain steady until March 31, 2026. [icbc.com]
So when you hear “switch and save,” it is usually about:
- Optional coverage choices
- Discounts
- Deductibles
- Driver factors (mileage, use, household drivers)
If you want a simple refresher that covers BC’s no-fault context too, this internal guide helps: no-fault insurance in Canada.
Alberta: do not miss the 2026 “good driver” cap
Alberta states rates for eligible good drivers are capped at 7.5% in 2025 and 2026, with eligibility rules (including no minor convictions within the past 3 years). [Alberta.ca]
If your renewal jumped hard, ask:
• “Do I qualify for the good driver cap?”
• “If not, what disqualifies me?”
• “Is this a renewal increase, or did something change on my policy?”
Alberta is also planning bigger system changes in the next couple years. If you want the plain-English version: Alberta auto insurance reform.
A practical way to compare without wasting a weekend
Here is where most people get burned: they “shop around” and end up with repeated forms, repeated calls, and their info floating around more than they wanted.
The BeatMyInsurance approach (privacy-first)
Instead of you chasing quotes, brokers compete for your business.
✅ Ready to compare privately?
Start a free auto insurance quote and review competing bids. Accept one, and only then share contact details.
Broker vs direct: the “what you actually pay for” table
| What you care about | Broker channel | Direct channel |
|---|---|---|
| Number of insurers you can compare | Often multiple (depends on broker markets) | One insurer |
| Guidance on coverage tradeoffs | Usually yes | Sometimes limited (depends on rep) |
| Claims help / advocacy | Can be strong (varies) | Depends on insurer |
| Time spent shopping | Lower if broker does comparison | Higher if you compare multiple direct writers |
| Privacy risk while comparing | High on many quote sites (unless privacy-first model) | Moderate (one insurer), still not “private comparison” |
| The “commission” issue | Exists, commonly disclosed ranges (often ~10%–12.5% for personal auto). [Chubb] | No broker commission, but insurer still has distribution costs |
A simple checklist before choosing broker or direct
If the goal is the lowest premium:
• What coverage changed (deductibles, endorsements, optional benefits)?
• Are accident benefits different (Ontario especially after July 1, 2026)?
• Is the policy truly comparable, or just “cheaper”?
If the goal is best value (price + protection):
• Can multiple insurers be compared quickly?
• Will your information stay controlled while you compare?
• Can someone explain the tradeoffs in plain English?
So… are you paying a “hidden 15%” in Ontario, BC, or Alberta?
Sometimes broker commission is part of the premium structure, yes. But “15%” isn’t a safe blanket number, and “remove commission = save money” is usually not how pricing works in Car Insurance Broker vs Direct comparisons.
What is consistently true in 2026:
- Ontario: coverage choices matter more because of the July 1, 2026 accident benefits changes. [FSRA Ontario]
- BC: Basic is ICBC, and big savings claims are usually about optional coverage and discounts, not “escaping commission.” [icbc.com]
- Alberta: if eligible, the 7.5% cap is a real lever to understand at renewal. [Alberta.ca]
Call to action: compare privately, no pressure
If you want to compare broker options without opening the spam floodgates, use a private-bid approach:
- Share your needs
- Review competing offers
- Keep your details private until you accept
🚀 Start here
Begin your free auto insurance quote and let brokers compete.
Notes (for trust)
This is general information, not legal advice or a coverage recommendation. For Ontario-specific broker disclosures, RIBO guidance emphasizes disclosure no later than the time of quote. [RIBO]
References
- Chubb – Intermediary Compensation Practices
- FSRA Ontario – Changes in Statutory Accident Benefits coverage (July 1, 2026)
- ICBC – News release re: rebate and basic rates remain steady until March 31, 2026
- Alberta.ca – Automobile insurance reform (rate cap info)
- RIBO – Providing Mandatory Disclosure
- ICBC – What impacts the cost of your insurance?
🔒 Compare Without the Spam Flood
Want to compare broker options privately? Start a free auto insurance quote and see competing bids. Your contact info stays private until you accept one.
Leave a Reply